Introduction to Buddhism: The Bird and The Worm


Today we began to study our fourth religion: Buddhism.

Buddhism is sometimes called a "philosophy" rather than a religion, since many Buddhists choose not to focus on the question of whether god (or another higher power) exists. In this class, though, we are going to classify Buddhism as a religion.

------------

The Buddha was very interested in the topic of suffering. He asked a number of deep questions: Why do people and other creatures suffer? Is it possible to escape from suffering? How can humans lessen the amount of suffering in the world?

To begin thinking about these questions, I posed a couple of "thought questions" to the students today. They came up with fantastic responses:

Question #1: What would you think if you saw a bird eat a worm? How would you feel? Would you do anything?

Dylan: I like the idea of a bird eating a worm because it reminds me of nature. Sure, I feel bad for the worm, but whenever I see a bird eat one it makes me feel calm. And, since I don’t see worms or birds close up very often, I feel like it’s a privilege to see this kind of sight. I think it cool to see things like this, because it’s such a rare occasion, right? The ground must be moist, and there has to be a bird flying around to see the worm. You can’t look just anywhere and see this kind of thing, you have to wait and be patient.

Malcolm: If I saw a bird eat a worm, philosophically it would be a very interesting event. You can either watch the worm’s life come to a sudden stop, or you can intervene. The choice seems obvious, but think about what happens if the bird does not eat the worm. The bird, or the bird’s children, will go hungry because they have no food to eat.

Reese: I would be sad, but I wouldn’t try to stop the bird. The bird was just acting on its natural instinct to feed itself (and perhaps its mate and hatchlings), and stopping the bird from eating the worm would just make it harder for the bird to feed its family.

Bella: If people stopped birds from eating worms, then worms would overpopulate and all of the birds would die due to the lack of food. It's like the food cycle that we learned about in 3rd grade -- if certain animals stop eating other animals, the animals that we want around will die and the animals that we don’t want around will overpopulate. Also I don’t think I would feel very bad for the worm because it would probably die anyway, because of another animal or a human deciding to step on it. The worm might as well be useful and feed the bird.

Logan: This is the circle of life. This bird could be a mother. She could have babies that are starved because of recent cold weather. Varying species of worms live up to nine years. Worms are prey. They are kinda cute and serve a purpose to the food chain other than being eaten. I’m sorry, Worm Daddy, Mommy, and Siblings, but this worm has been done no injustice.

Sammy: If the bird is small I’d let it eat the worm to continue the cycle of life, but if the bird is big then it would not need the worm to survive and I would scare the bird away. It could be a hard decision because the bird might be in the middle of the two, so I would judge based on how hungry or aggressive the bird looked, then decide whether the circle of life would continue or I would scare the bird away. If I chose to save the worm's life I would return it to a safer area where fewer birds could see it.

Isabelle V.: I would feel bad for the worm because it was just living its life and got eaten. I do understand that’s just the way the food chain works, but it still makes me sad. A lot of people say they don’t really care and I always try to put myself in both the worm's and the bird's situation. Imagine if you were a worm on the side of the road and you became someone else’s dinner. The bird needed the food to live and to bring to its children, but it still makes me upset when people say, “Oh it’s just a worm.”

Carson N.: When you think about the situation from the worm's perspective, it would care a lot. The worm does not want to die.

James B.: I would feel bad for the worm. I realize that worms are one of the main thing birds eat and and there's nothing they can do about it. But then I would think, what did that worm ever do to hurt the bird or try to demolish the bird? I think that I would genuinely feel bad for the worm.

Carter: It is sad and a little bit depressing to see at first, but then if you put some thought into it, it has to be that way. I don’t think that you really can do anything, sadly. You can’t talk to the bird and tell it next time not to do that. I think that if I saw a worm getting hurt for another reason (for example, if a worm was about to get stepped on), I would pick up the worm and move it safely somewhere else. In this case, I would not do anything because there is nothing really to do.

Question #2: What would you think if you saw a 5th grader being mean to a 3rd grader? How would you feel? Would you do anything?

Timmy: I would go over to those kids and tell the 5th grader that he should not be doing that. Like Mr. Jones said, you shouldn’t add to someone's burden. Maybe they aren’t having a great day and you could have just made it worse. Or they were having a great day, but you ruined it.

Xavier: I would do something about it, but the problem wouldn’t be resolved with fighting. Instead, I would ask the person why are they doing this, and if they gave no answer, then I would ask them politely to go away. If they didn't leave, then I’d take the third grader somewhere else and I’d play with them to make them feel better.

Rowen: I would feel bad and try to do something to help the third grader ... This scenario is different from the worm scenario because this encounter with the fifth grader could have a huge impact on the third grader, whereas in the other scenario the worm won’t live to tell the tale, so it won’t have any impact on the worm. I think that I would definitely try to help the third grader so it wouldn't have a bad impact on him or her.

Trey: I would step in and protect the third grader. Bullying is not right, and nobody on the face of the earth should have to deal with being bullied, EVER, on their time on this planet.

Liam B.: I would not feel just sad but very angry, too. If somebody is hurting somebody else that is wrong, very wrong ... I would step into the problem and tell the bully to knock it off. If they did not stop then I would tell a worthy adult what happened. Bullying is very wrong, and as long as I live I will not let that happen to anyone.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Johann Gutenberg: Did He Tweet, Too?!

The Fire at Notre Dame Cathedral

Musical Monday Selections